In Blog

best-solar-inverter-7If you are looking for the best solar inverter for your home, the answer does not necessarily come from a “best solar inverter 2019” list. There are four different inverter solutions you will want to consider, depending on your particular home and your personal preferences.

This blog will help you easily navigate your way through the nightmare that is choosing the best solar inverter for your home. We’ll start by comparing leading “shade solutions” and standard string inverters. Next, should you find out that your best option is to keep with a string inverter (as often is the case) then you can refer to the best solar inverter (string inverter) comparison chart in Part 2 (click here).

 

Part 1

String inverters vs. Micros vs. Optimisers

There are two ways to do solar. The easy way and the hard way. The easy way is to install one string inverter on the ground. Simple, affordable, and fewer parts that can fail. The hard way is to install power electronics behind panels on the roof – and (usually) an inverter on the ground. Why would you choose the complex and expensive way? The table below shows why the hard way may-or-may-not be the best for your situation.

The one-word explanation in the table needs further clarification.  So for each point in the table, I have elaborated comments below the table.

“No” doesn’t necessarily mean “No”. Read the comments below for a fuller answer.

Comparing the features of 4 different types of inverters

  String inverters (eg: Fronius, SMA, Sungrow)String inverter + optimisers (Tigo or Huawei)
Microinverters (Enphase, APS)Solaredge
I want quality and bang for buck.YesYesNoNo
Serviceability after the warranty period is important to me.YesNoNoNo
I want my panels to perform at their maximum capacity.YesYesNoNo
I don't want to be locked into one brand should something go wrong.YesYesNoNo
My roof is tiny: 4 panels north, 3 east, 7 west.NoYesYesNo
I've got Voltage Rise issues.YesYesNoYes
I've need panels north, east and west.YesYesYesNo
I live in a unit and body corporate is a nightmare.NoNo YesNo
I live in a rainforest and I still want solar.NoNoYesNo
I want to see how every panel is performing.NoYesYesYes
I want "rapid shutdown". Safety first.NoYesYesYes
My roof has light or medium shading.NoYesYesYes

 

I want quality and bang for buck

If you just want a quality affordable solar inverter and you don’t have a complicated roof, my best advice is to keep it simple and install a string inverter (eg Fronius, SMA, Sungrow). While rooftop power electronics allow for greater flexibility, it’s also more expensive and often the pros outweigh the cons.
Which is the best string inverter? I’ve given my take at the bottom of this blog.

 

 

Serviceability outside of warranty is important to me

The problem with putting power electronics (optimisers or micro-inverters) on your roof is if they fail, someone has to get on your roof and lift a panel (sometimes several panels) to replace the failed product. If the brackets holding your panels down are 10 years old – it’s likely to turn into a nightmare. Panel clamps often seize and it’s difficult to find replacements. So if you’re looking for simplicity, forget optimisers and micros. Put a simple string inverter (like Fronius) near your switchboard. Easy peasy.

On the flip side, Enphase has a unique advantage over every other solution because it does not have a central point of failure (an inverter on the ground). If one Microinverter fails, the rest will keep working. If you have panel-level monitoring and notice one micro is down, then your production loss can be minimal.

 

 

I want my panels to perform at their maximum capacity

Many electricity distributors used to restrict single-phase homes to a 5kW inverter. Because of this restriction, we used to run that inverter as hard as we were allowed – with 6.6kW of panels. Now that we can install 10kW inverters on single-phase homes, oversizing to 33 per cent is becoming less common.

A common system for us to install today is 9.9kW of panels on an 8.2kW single phase inverter (oversized by 20%). We usually install the 30 panels in multiple orientations so the panels won’t peak their output at the same time. This allows the panels to share the capacity of the 8.2kW inverter throughout the course of the day, so they are not limited to 80% of their maximum output.

Micro-inverters are different. Because micro-inverters use only one inverter per panel,  Enphase can’t “capacity share” as string inverters can. Instead, each panel is always limited to the output of its micro-inverter. So to reduce inverter clipping, it’s best not to install a panel that is anywhere near 33 per cent bigger than the output of your Enphase micro-inverter. We recommend a maximum of 10 to 15 per cent oversizing to minimise panel clipping. This will marginally increase the cost of your Enphase system. It will also marginally increase your production and stop the frustration of seeing your panels clipping. This may not be a huge financial saving, but If you purchased Enphase to maximised production, it’s a factor worth considering.

The graph below compares the peak output capacity of the three Enphase micro-inverter models available and show the recommended maximum panel size to prevent power clipping.

Enphase comparison

Enphase Micro Inverter modelPeak output10% oversized panel (recommended)15% oversized panel (borderline)30% oversized panel (not recommended)
Enphase IQ 7250 W275W287 W325W
Enphase IQ 7+295 W324 W339W383W
Enphase IQ 7X320 W352W368416W
  • Common panel sizes now start at 300W. The IQ7 is a bad choice if you want to maximise production.
  • The IQ7+ is suitable for 300 to 330W panels.
  • The IQ 7X is designed for higher voltage panels: SunPower 350W and 360W panels.

In the table above I say “no” for SolarEdge because of the potential of the blocking issues described in my SolarEdge review.

 

 

I don’t want to be locked into one brand should something go wrong

The best solar inverters are interchangeable. Should Fronius, SMA, ABB or Sungrow go pear shaped in 5 years time, you can swap out your old inverter with the next best solar inverter. This is definitely not the case with Solaredge. SolarEdge inverters need SolarEdge optimisers. Even today’s models of SolarEdge optimisers are not fully interchangeable.

Should Enphase go bust or peeve you off, it would be possible to replace one Enphase Micro with another brand. You would, however, lose your monitoring capability of that panel.

Should Tigo go belly up, you could replace a Tigo optimiser with a Huawei optimiser. This solution is not currently warranted by Huawei, but it works. You would lose monitoring of that panel but still have the inverter monitoring.

 

My roof is tiny: 4 panels north, 3 east, 7 west

The above is obviously just an example, but chopped up complicated roofs often need optimisers or micro-inverter. Enphase, Tigo or Huawei are your options.

If you are looking for the best solar inverter for a complicated roof, I would steer away from SolarEdge due to blocking issues and a bunch of other reasons that I explain in this SolarEdge review.

 

I’ve got voltage rise issues

Voltage rise is sometimes a significant electricity grid issue that can make your solar system turn off in the middle of the day. It’s a fairly complex issue explained in detail in this post. If you have potential voltage rise issues, we’ll need to minimise voltage rise by minimising the length of the AC cable run and maximise the size of the AC cable.

If you choose a string inverter, this is simple. We install your inverter next to the switchboard and use 10mm cables. In this situation, we might only contribute 0.2% to voltage rise.

If, however, you choose a micro-inverter, we’ll need to run longer AC cables to your roof, and run small Enphase AC cables to every panel.  On a high set complex roof, it may not be feasible to minimise the voltage rise on an Enphase system below 1%.

Not every Enphase system will have a voltage rise problem, but if you are looking for the best solar inverter solution, it is a problem worth considering.

 

I need panels north, east and west

Installing panels on three roof orientations is bread and butter for optimisers and micro-inverters. However many people in the industry don’t realise that you can also achieve the same outcome with the right string inverter. You need an inverter with around 18 amps DC input current like the “Fronius Primo SC” solar inverter. Read my post about the best way to install solar North East and West on a string inverter.

Again I mention “no ” for SolarEdge just to point out a potential blocking issue. Of course, if designed with long strings (longer than 10 panels) blocking may not occur. But this is often not possible.

 

I live in a unit and body corporate is a nightmare

Enphase is often the best solar inverter solution for body corporate situations.

  • It’s cost-effective for smaller systems.
  • It works well on any small multi-orientation roof.
  • Because the inverters are on the roof, you only have a comparatively indiscrete box to install on a communal wall or in your unit.
  • Because we run AC cable from the roof, the cable run can usually be more discrete and snuck inside wall cavities.

The other brand of Micro-inverter is AP Systems or APS micro-inverters. AP systems have had all kinds of issues in the past and I would recommend steering clear.

 

Best MicroInverter 2019

I live in a rainforest and still want solar

Enphase is hands down the best solar inverter solution if your shading is extreme. Every other solution requires 4 to 6 panels in the sun in order for the solar to produce anything. SolarEdge will likely suffer from blocking or may turn off. Enphase (micro-inverters) offers the only solution that will keep on running when all of the panels are shaded except one.

 

Solar Panel MonitoringI want to see how every panel is performing

While it’s possible to get panel-level monitoring when using optimisers, you can’t assume you are going to get it. This is because Solar Sales companies don’t want retired engineers calling them up asking why one panel is performing 5 watts less than the next. If you want that data, you may need to ask for it.

 

  • Enphase recently released basic panel level data to customers for free! Nice one.
  • SolarEdge gives the sales company the option to restrict your access when they set up your monitoring.
  • Tigo is only available if you pay for extra hardware and installation.
  • Huawei gives you panel-level monitoring as standard.

 

I want rapid shutdown: Safety First

Rapid shutdown means if you turn off the main switch off at your house, there will be no electricity generated from your panels travelling through your roof. It’s a safety measure in case of a fire.

Enphase is always the safest system in theory because there is never DC power running from your panels to your inverter, and the AC power shuts off as soon as the power is off to your house.

Tigo (coupled with any string inverter mentioned below) requires the “Cloud Connect” to be installed to activate rapid shutdown. This is an additional cost.

Huawei will have rapid shutdown once they integrate Henry the Octopus (the safety box) into the inverter (coming in 2020).

SolarEdge has rapid shutdown by default, but it still has DC running through your roof during normal operation. And SolarEdge is not one of the best solar inverters for many other reasons.

 

Best Solar Inverter 3My roof has minor or medium shading

The problem with shading on just one panel is it can bring down the production of half of the panels on your roof. Shading, bypass diodes and solar panel power electronics is a complex discussion.

If you have minor or medium shade issues, I believe the best solar inverter and optimiser solution is a Fronius Inverter with Tigo optimisers on the shaded panels. If the shade issues are significant, we recommend Tigo or Enphase. Huawei inverters with Huawei optimisers may also be an option for partial or full shade.

 

Part 2

Which is the Best Solar Inverter? (string)

It’s a straight up question and for the last couple of years, I’ve had a straight up answer. If you’ve chosen to go with a string inverter (with a possibility of Tigo optimisers) then the best solar inverter is hands down Fronius. The Austrian made inverter has been the market leader in Australia for flexibility of design, ease of use, in-depth online monitoring, durability, and after-sales support. Because of its popularity, Fronius occasionally has supply issues – especially for the solar installers who don’t pre-order their stock. You know a shonky solar sales company when they go around bagging out Fronius and trying to justify why their string inverter is better.

The Next-To-Best Solar Inverters

That’s not to say there is no place for other inverters: With Fronius, you pay a premium to get the best. And it’s not to say other inverters cannot be equal in some applications. It’s just Fronius seems to be great at everything, and they have a solution for almost everything residential. When we custom design a solar solution for your home, our go-to is always Fronius.

If you choose another inverter, SMA is a decent inverter and a great company. While their single-phase inverters are still being made in China, their manufacturing is bit-by-bit moving back to Germany. I reviewed SMA a few years ago, but admittedly it’s overdue a revisit.

Huawei’s solutions are very limited at the moment. However if their solution is right for you, then a Huawei inverter would be a safe gamble. I visited the Huawei factory in China recently. Huawei will have a wider and more flexible range of inverters on offer in 2020.

You could also choose ABB – A solid company and it seems the inverter has finally got consumption monitoring. The 5kW isn’t as flexible as the Fronius and they don’t offer the same range. But if it works for your roofline, the ABB is still a good inverter. The concern installers have with ABB is their warranty process. Quality installers want to make sure they can look after any of their customer’s warranty issues on their own – that’s just good customer service. But ABB chooses to deal directly with the end-user to sort out the warranty. In the past, warranties have taken several months to honour and warranties have been refused without good reason. The ABB Australia team have tried hard to get this warranty process to run fairly and efficiently and some reports say ABB has made huge improvements. Others installers seem so jaded with ABB that it seems nothing will win them back. Hopefully, ABB can keep things improving and regain industry trust.

Best Budget Solar InverterThe best budget Solar Inverter

The best inverter on the budget range is easily Sungrow. The Chinese company, Sungrow is the second biggest inverter manufacturer in the world. While Sungrow had fairly significant failures five years ago, the service department in Australia was extremely pro-active. Sungrow has recently increased their range of inverters. They now include an 8kW single phase and three 5kW, 10kW and 15kW three-phase inverters. Their monitoring platform has significantly improved and they are soon to release a consumption monitoring option.

There are inverters on the market that are significantly cheaper than Sungrow. And it is possible that one of these inverters will do the job. But I haven’t found another budget inverter that I’d recommend. There are plenty that I’d recommend you avoid. The poor man will pay twice.

 

Conclusion

When it comes to the best solar inverters on the market, there is no one size fits all. Micro-inverters have a place in the market for small, shaded and complicated roofs. SolarEdge is popular, but my experience has shown SolarEdge has far too many issues and limitations. Huawei is the new kid on the block and an inverter worth watching. If you don’t need the bells and whistles, Fronius is the best string inverter: uncomplicated, robust, and flexible.  You can pair Tigo with Fronius if you have shade issues. Finally, if you want a really simple budget inverter, go with Sungrow – but don’t go any cheaper than that.

14 Comments on Best Solar inverter 2019

brendan said : Guest Report 7 days ago

I am senior solar installer as well, Goodwee will be much better than sungrow. the prices are similar.

  • 2100
Mark C said : administrator Report a week ago

Hi Victoria. I agree it's not a huge issue. I probably pressed the point harder than I needed to. But I think it balances the common claim that Enphase generates more power due to mismatch. This is a mute point if you are significantly clipping each panel in perfect conditions. I do think Enphase is a niche product that works best in shaded or complicated roofs. But it's mainly because of serviceability.

Mark C said : administrator Report a week ago

Hi Margot, Yes we have that issue with Fronius occasionally. Reality is we need to install them in a similar location to a small outdoor aircon unit. And I have heard issues where the fan was faulty and ran continually.

Margot Kiesskalt said : Guest Report a week ago

Another very informative article Mark. Have you received any feedback about excessive fan noise on some inverters? One installer posted a video on this on the "Crap Solar" Facebook page on 24-Feb-2019 with the comment: “Anyone else experiencing ridiculously loud fan noise being excreted from inverters? And getting bloody hot to touch exterior of? I've got 2 that customers are losing it because of how loud it is but tried to make a claim due to noisy fan today with

  • 3199
Tony said : Guest Report a week ago

We've had our Fronius 5kw inverter and 20 panels for 4 years now and are very happy with the savings we've received. Wouldn't use any other brand 👍👍Thanks for your blogs Mark

  • 4030
Victoria said : Guest Report a week ago

Great analysis! I work at an Enphase only shop and was struck by your opinion that Enphase produces enough power clipping to generate an entire paragraph. It makes it seem that that is a significant enough issue that people should stay away from microinverters unless they're in very shady areas. I asked my boss about it and he pointed me to this paper to read up a little more on the issue: https://runonsun.com/~runons5/blogs/media/blogs/a/Enphase_White_Paper_Module_Rightsizing.pdf?mtime=1360003648 In reading the paper, which is from 2013 and looks at the issue from the standpoint of M215's and sub-300 watt panels, I'm not sold on the idea that power clipping is as big a deal as it seems in this write-up. Although the numbers have changed from 2013 the issues of panel performance in the field versus the lab as well as panel degradation, soiling, location and temperature all seem like vital factors that vastly negate the idea of power clipping as a black mark against micro-inverters. Please see the quote from the paper below that addresses my views: "...lifetime losses to inverter saturation will likely be lower, due to module degradation and increased soiling over time. This study highlights the need to evaluate solar modules based on their expected field performance, rather than their nameplate rating. Solar modules will only perform to their nameplate rating during select weather conditions, when the sun shines brightly and the temperature is cold. Overall, these conditions are rare, only occurring on a small percentage of days in the late winter and early spring. Whereas, most sunny days throughout the year have higher temperatures, which typically reduce the module’s output to 80% or less of its nameplate rating." Thoughts?

  • 91101
Gullp said : Guest Report a week ago

Enphase panel level monitoring is now free of charge and standard for all end customers since the last software upgrade dating May 2019 as far as I am aware.

  • 0830
Guillermo Rivera said : Guest Report a week ago

Great job Mark, thanks and congratulations. I will be waiting for more great news.

  • 5000001
Mark C said : administrator Report 2 weeks ago

Hi Ziyad. Fair call. Back up is generally not on my radar because it doesn't make financial sense. And good point about the postcode. I checked and about 75 per cent of our readers are from Australia. But postcode is a useless metric! We'll get rid of it :)

Paul NASH said : Guest Report 2 weeks ago

Cannot believe how much detail MC Electrical puts out there for "free" to potential clients etc . This guy knows his stuff but far more important is that he clearly LOVES what he does in relation to solar installations ( bit like me in reading this solar stuff when i get a chance to) Keep up the great work I say Well done

  • 4109
Luke McDermott said : Guest Report 2 weeks ago

Best equipment comparison I've ever seen.

  • 2477
Chris Harvey said : Guest Report 2 weeks ago

Another great Blog. Thanks Mark.

  • 6168
Keiran said : Guest Report 2 weeks ago

Another great blog post, thanks Mark. I hope you realise how a great a resource your blog is for people in the solar industry that aren't as connected on a day-to-day basis with household installations as you are! :)

  • 3000
Ziyad said : Guest Report 2 weeks ago

Except fronius doesn't have a proper backup solution. They say it can operate in backup mode for 15% of the time. Something to do with 53Hz that fronius inverter operates in backup mode. Btw why do you need postcode for comments. Are all your viewers in Australia.

  • 54570

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

Subscribe To Mark's Blog

Subscribe To Mark's Blog

Join our mailing list to receive the latest information, reviews and solar industry insights from MC Electrical owner Mark Cavanagh.

You have Successfully Subscribed!